Lies and Deceit Plague Clinical Trials

The publicity around the current COVID vaccine clinical trials has done much to make the public aware of the difficulties researchers face to ensure the safety and effectiveness of the therapy being tested.

Besides the now well-known need to recruit participants representing all age groups, races, and other demographics, clinical trial managers also have to be on the lookout to avoid what the pharma community has come to call “professional study subjects.”

These individuals are so eager to participate in a clinical study they lie about their medical condition, misrepresent their lifestyle, fail to disclose medications they take and may participate in more than one, even several studies simultaneously.

Eric Devine, PhD, assistant professor of psychiatry at Boston University School of Medicine, says, “I was doing clinical trials and I was running into people who were just lying to me. It was blatant when I looked at their medical records.”

Money is what motivates most professional study subjects, according to a Medscape report. Many trials pay participants, enabling some to earn thousands of dollars. One man who entered an Alzheimer’s trial legitimately earned $31,000.

Others may be driven to participate because of free medical treatment. The Medscape report mentions one woman who lied to get into a trial involving botulinum toxin. “I wanted to get into the study. I wanted free Botox, so I participated. And I got paid — so why wouldn’t I?”

study of the problem published in 2013 found 75% of the subjects who had participated in at least two trials in the previous year admitted concealing some important medical information:

  • 32% hid health problems
  • 28% concealed their use of prescribed medications
  • 20% failed to disclose their recreational drug use
  • 14% reported pretending to have a health condition in order to qualify.

Even when these professional study subjects have more altruistic motives, their deception can skew trial results. If enough of these types of study subjects manage to enroll – and the estimate is that as many as 25% of volunteers apply in a way that violates trial criteria – the results can be skewed.

Medscape says misrepresentation can be serious enough to “invalidate outcomes and even halt further research.”

Subject registries exist to attempt to catch the professional subjects. When detected, these individuals can be entered in a registry. Recently, these registries have begun to incorporate biometric data to foil the professional subjects who have used fake identification.

“That can sound very ‘Big Brother-ish’,” Devine says. “But think about the quality of our information — it can either be lifesaving or not. Do we really want to take a chance with medicine as a science, and leave it up to ‘Well, I hope we didn’t have too many professional subjects in this trial?’ “

Photo by Mehmet Turgut Kirkgoz on Unsplash

Best Practices for Performance Reviews
General Interest

Best Practices for Performance Reviews

Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace
General Interest

Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Tim Coonan
Architecture + Engineering General Interest

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Tim Coonan

Green Key Unlocked: Soft Skills Recruiters Should Have in the Age of AI
General Interest

Green Key Unlocked: Soft Skills Recruiters Should Have in the Age of AI

The Power of Feedback in The Workplace
General Interest

The Power of Feedback in The Workplace

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Ariana Ali
General Interest Worklife

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Ariana Ali

Green Key Named Best Executive Search Firm in Hedgeweek Awards
Accounting + Finance General Interest

Green Key Named Best Executive Search Firm in Hedgeweek Awards

LinkedIn Reaches 1B Users and Launches New AI Tools
General Interest

LinkedIn Reaches 1B Users and Launches New AI Tools

The Soft Skills Tech Talent Need
General Interest Information Technology

The Soft Skills Tech Talent Need

Upskilling: Your Path to Personal and Professional Growth
General Interest

Upskilling: Your Path to Personal and Professional Growth

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Trisha Hankins
General Interest Healthcare

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Trisha Hankins

Green Key Unlocked: Navigating a Career Transition to Analytics
General Interest Information Technology

Green Key Unlocked: Navigating a Career Transition to Analytics

Team Dynamics Deciphered: A Guide to Finding Your Place as a New Member
General Interest Worklife

Team Dynamics Deciphered: A Guide to Finding Your Place as a New Member

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Krista Zielinski
General Interest Pharma

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Krista Zielinski

We Stand with Israel
General Interest

We Stand with Israel

Time Blindness: Impact and Management
General Interest Human Resources

Time Blindness: Impact and Management

Things You Shouldn’t Say During the Salary Negotiation Process
General Interest Human Resources Professional Support Worklife

Things You Shouldn’t Say During the Salary Negotiation Process

Salary Negotiations: Strategize Your Worth
General Interest Human Resources Professional Support

Salary Negotiations: Strategize Your Worth

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Brad Martin
Architecture + Engineering General Interest

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Brad Martin

Green Key Unlocked: Mastering your Healthcare Interview
General Interest Healthcare

Green Key Unlocked: Mastering your Healthcare Interview

Latest Blog Posts
View All Posts
Best Practices for Performance Reviews

Best Practices for Performance Reviews

Performance reviews, often met with anxiety and anticipation, are an integral part to a thriving workplace and the cornerstone of...
Read More
Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace

Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace

Cultural sensitivity is a pivotal factor in creating a workplace where every individual can flourish.
Read More
#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Tim Coonan

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Tim Coonan

Tim started his recruiting career almost five years ago when he transitioned from an accounting and sports marketing career.
Read More