It’s Ethical to Pay COVID Volunteers

It is ethically appropriate to pay volunteers who are intentionally infected with the COVID virus as part of clinical research, says an international panel of experts.

In a report published in the American Journal of Bioethics, the group of ethicists, lawyers, academics, laymen and others from the UK, United States, and Canada found that paying participants in a COVID study should be decided the same way as other human infection challenge studies (HICS) and other, traditional types of clinical trials and research studies.

“Our work was spurred by concerns that payment for SARS-CoV-2 HICS might require a novel ethical framework, which we ultimately determined to be unfounded,” wrote lead author Holly Fernandez Lynch, an assistant professor of medical ethics at the University of Pennsylvania.

The report states that, “The basic framework for ethical research payment divides payment into three categories — reimbursement, compensation, and incentive — and emphasizes the importance of fairness and adequate recruitment and retention, with efforts to minimize undue influence, participant deception about their eligibility and adverse events, and negative impacts on public trust.

“The basic framework is relevant to payment for all types of clinical research, including HICS. Nonetheless, there are factors within that basic framework likely to be particularly salient to setting payment amounts for HICS, including participant isolation and confinement, anticipated discomfort, risk of lasting harm, and participant motivations.”

The panel concluded that payments for HICS and in particular for possible studies involving infection with the COVID virus, “will likely be on the high end of the payment spectrum.”

The report was sponsored by 1Day Sooner, an organization that promotes the use of human challenge trials. Unlike the trials bioscience companies like Pfizer and Modena used to test their vaccines, HCIS researchers intentionally inject volunteers with the virus they are testing against to study their reaction.

It is not uncommon to pay participants in clinical studies. Most often the payments are modest, compensating volunteers them for direct expenses and for their time. Some studies offer additional payments as incentives to recruit enough volunteers, including from diverse communities.

1Day Sooner assembled the study group – paying some of its members – to get an independent assessment of the ethics of whether and how much people should get paid to take part in COVID challenge trials. Such a study is planned in the United Kingdom.

The published report discusses multiple factors of the decision framework the group outlines, ultimately concluding that payment decision-making for HCIS – and COVID studies — should be the same as for all other clinical research involving human subjects.

Image by PIRO4D

Is Curiosity a Recruiter’s Superpower?
General Interest

Is Curiosity a Recruiter’s Superpower?

Best Practices for Performance Reviews
General Interest

Best Practices for Performance Reviews

Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace
General Interest

Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Tim Coonan
Architecture + Engineering General Interest

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Tim Coonan

Green Key Unlocked: Soft Skills Recruiters Should Have in the Age of AI
General Interest

Green Key Unlocked: Soft Skills Recruiters Should Have in the Age of AI

The Power of Feedback in The Workplace
General Interest

The Power of Feedback in The Workplace

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Ariana Ali
General Interest Worklife

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Ariana Ali

Green Key Named Best Executive Search Firm in Hedgeweek Awards
Accounting + Finance General Interest

Green Key Named Best Executive Search Firm in Hedgeweek Awards

LinkedIn Reaches 1B Users and Launches New AI Tools
General Interest

LinkedIn Reaches 1B Users and Launches New AI Tools

The Soft Skills Tech Talent Need
General Interest Information Technology

The Soft Skills Tech Talent Need

Upskilling: Your Path to Personal and Professional Growth
General Interest

Upskilling: Your Path to Personal and Professional Growth

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Trisha Hankins
General Interest Healthcare

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Trisha Hankins

Green Key Unlocked: Navigating a Career Transition to Analytics
General Interest Information Technology

Green Key Unlocked: Navigating a Career Transition to Analytics

Team Dynamics Deciphered: A Guide to Finding Your Place as a New Member
General Interest Worklife

Team Dynamics Deciphered: A Guide to Finding Your Place as a New Member

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Krista Zielinski
General Interest Pharma

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Krista Zielinski

We Stand with Israel
General Interest

We Stand with Israel

Time Blindness: Impact and Management
General Interest Human Resources

Time Blindness: Impact and Management

Things You Shouldn’t Say During the Salary Negotiation Process
General Interest Human Resources Professional Support Worklife

Things You Shouldn’t Say During the Salary Negotiation Process

Salary Negotiations: Strategize Your Worth
General Interest Human Resources Professional Support

Salary Negotiations: Strategize Your Worth

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Brad Martin
Architecture + Engineering General Interest

#WeAreGreenKey: Spotlight on Brad Martin

Latest Blog Posts
View All Posts
Is Curiosity a Recruiter’s Superpower?

Is Curiosity a Recruiter’s Superpower?

As the recruitment landscape continues to evolve, one skill stands out as a game changer: curiosity.
Read More
Best Practices for Performance Reviews

Best Practices for Performance Reviews

Performance reviews, often met with anxiety and anticipation, are an integral part to a thriving workplace and the cornerstone of...
Read More
Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace

Cultural Sensitivity in the Workplace

Cultural sensitivity is a pivotal factor in creating a workplace where every individual can flourish.
Read More